Alani Nu fans hoping for another sip of Pumpkin Cream Energy Drink may be disappointed this fall. After making its debut in 2025, the limited-edition flavor is not expected to return for the 2026 fall season.

Pumpkin Cream originally appeared inside the Alani Nu Fall Favorites Variety Pack, which included nine cans of the returning caramel-apple-inspired Witch's Brew and only three cans of Pumpkin Cream. The unusual pumpkin-spice energy drink quickly became difficult to find, with fans searching Kroger, Hy-Vee, Walmart and other retailers for the seasonal pack.

Despite mixed reactions online, Pumpkin Cream earned serious praise for its creamy pumpkin-dessert flavor. Sporked awarded it an impressive 9/10 rating, describing it as a surprisingly successful combination of pumpkin, warm spices and creamy sweetness.

Now, the absence of Alani Nu Pumpkin Cream from the 2026 fall energy drink lineup means any remaining cans could become collector-worthy finds. Witch's Brew may continue carrying Alani Nu's Halloween tradition, but Pumpkin Cream appears to have been a one-season experiment.

Unless Alani Nu surprises fans with a late announcement, Pumpkin Cream Energy Drink is officially missing fall 2026—and once the remaining cans disappear, they may be gone for good.